Wednesday, February 15, 2017

Depression: All about getting deep-rest

Hello, Beautiful World!

How has another week gone by already?!? Time is going by way too fast, and I simply don't know what to do about it (maybe it's having too much free time and not much stress). I've been going through a new book almost every day, which means I'm going to bed later and later than normal.


It's been another amazing week at A New Beginning (it's becoming my second-home!) 😊 Before I go ahead and begin talking about this week's mental health issue, I'd like to thank everyone who reads my blog because last week, I was announced blog-of-the-week! I'm so so happy that people are enjoying my topic/project/content so far, and I wanted to let you guys know that I really really appreciate it, and am so grateful for each and every one of you πŸ˜˜πŸ’•.  I'd also like to give a shout-out to four amazing people that mean so much to me: Dr. AnnΓ©, Taana, Mr. Chadwick, and my dad. This project would be nothing without the experience and knowledge I'm receiving from my internship at A New Beginning; and my 'week 1' post about anxiety wouldn't have had much substance without my meeting with Taana. I'd like to thank Mr. Chadwick for turning this simple idea into an actual project, and guiding me through it since he became my faculty advisor. Last but not least, thank you to my dad for always being there for me, and showing so much patience. I wouldn't be anything without the support and love he unconditionally gives me (from providing feedback on my posts to paying for the gas to get to my internship πŸ˜‚). 

Now, I'll begin with the mental health issue of the week: depression (are my puns getting better or worse?). Once again, I'd like to start off by giving some general statistics on depression (that AP Stats class is becoming very handy, I'm beginning to realize):
  • ~7%, or about 16 million, adults in the USA had a major depressive episode in their life in 2015.*
  • Major depression reduces the life span of a person, and "accounts for the most years lived with disability of any mental or behavioral disorder."*
  • The percentage of Americans taking antidepressants has increased from 6.8 to 12% from 1999 to 2012.*
  • By 2020, the global market for depression drugs is predicated to be worth over $16 billion.*
Something that seemed to be of interest to me about these particular statistics was that despite the increase of Americans taking antidepressants as a form of treatment, they were still suffering with depression for a longer time than those with other mental health issues. The question that I came up with is: are antidepressants not truly beneficial in the long-term? If not, then what form of treatment is, and why?


Similar to last week, I conducted a survey and found modern-day media about depression before going in to meet Taana (don't get too comfortable... we'll soon get to meet a different therapist πŸ˜‰). We started off the discussion by talking about what types of misconceptions patients generally come in with (just kidding... I actually forgot to ask this question during the meeting, and had to email her to ask it; but we'll overlook that tiny detail). Similar to anxiety disorder clients, those with depression also come in feeling shame and guilt that they haven't been able to 'fix' their depression or just 'get over it.' As we talked about this, I began to see a similar thread between the different mental health issues: the guilt, the shame.

From here, we talked more about depression as a disorder, once again using the survey as a basis for the questions: 

Misconceptions:
  • Myth: Depression is rare, and only affects people of certain backgrounds, race, and/or gender.
    • Truth: Depression is a lot more common than people realize; we can see this simply by looking at how many people get at least one depressive episode during their whole lifespan. In terms of it affecting people of certain backgrounds, races, or gender, depression is fairly universal. However, the statistics do tend to vary among cultures and genders due to whether it is culturally acceptable to report symptoms of depression and receive treatment. The actual incidence of depression is likely much higher than what is reported. 
  • Myth: Depression implies a weak character/personality.
    • Truth: Depression is very challenging for people to deal with, requiring a lot of strength and energy from a person compared to someone without it. So, instead of weakening one's character/personality, it builds his/her inner strength and courage.  
      • Side note: antidepressants do not affect one's character/personality.
  • Myth: One can get rid of his/her depression simply by putting a stop to his/her wallowing, and thinking more positively.
    • Truth: Absolutely not! Statements like this show that depression is so dangerously misunderstood in our society. It invalidates the person, and makes them feel shame and embarrassment when they can't just "get over it" or control their symptoms through "will power." Myths like this are damaging because they often prevent people from seeking readily available and effective treatment, especially when the myth is put forth by family members, teachers, or friends. 
Some things that can be myths or truths, depending upon the case:
  • Although depression can be caused by a negative incident, there are many other causes as well: 
    • Genetic pre-disposition (genes for depressive disorders can be passed along just like eye or hair color)
    • Hormones (especially in teenagers)
      • Side note: symptoms of depression in teenagers are more likely to be irritable mood, isolating behavior, or acting out with risk-taking or angry behavior
    • The grief process (feelings of depression are normal for a certain period of time after someone has experienced a loss - which can include loss of a relationship, loss of a job, loss of a goal one has been working toward, loss of lifestyle, in addition to loss of a person one is close to. If one doesn't mourn and process the loss in a healthy way, it can trigger an ongoing depression and/or suicidal thoughts)
    • Traumatic events (especially where people feel powerless)
      • Emotional trauma (repeated invalidating messages)
    • Depression can also result from some medical conditions
  • Someone on antidepressants doesn't necessarily have to take them for the rest of his/her life. The length of this form of treatment depends on a variety of factors: type of depression, the severity, what the trigger/cause is, and whether people are willing/able to use the skills taught in therapy.
  • Antidepressants are the most common form of treatment because they appear to be a fairly easy solution (one can simply get them from a primary care doctor, making it easier because he/she only has to ask one person and that too in secrecy). In fact, not all medical doctors are specialists in mental health issues; so when people go for the easier route through their primary care physician, they might not be getting the specialized information and care that mental health issues often require. However, medications aren't necessarily the most effective form of treatment, because they only treat the symptoms. With using medication alone, if a person stops taking the medication, their symptoms can return. Medications can also have side-effects that must be weighed with the benefits. Studies have also shown that regular exercise may be just as effective as taking antidepressants. When a person has Major Depression, the best course may be a combination of medication and therapy. However, therapy typically produces the most long-lasting results with fewer relapses. Why psychotherapy? Because it involves a holistic process of looking at everything going on in the person's life and how things may be impacting them, and creates a plan to help the person move forward with healthy behaviors, a healthy relationship with themselves, and healthy relationships with others. It aims to help people get to the root cause(s) of what may be causing the disturbance for them, helps people to face challenges in their lives in a healthy way, and helps to corrects any unhealthy beliefs that may be getting in the way of people reaching their potential. There is even some evidence that the process of therapy helps to re-wire a person’s brain in a healthy way. The reason antidepressants are used more commonly is because often it seems like an easier solution, and people may be (unnecessarily) fearful of the process of therapy because they don’t have enough information about what therapy is like, and/or they feel overwhelmed by their problems and again, feel shame and guilt that they can’t “just fix it” themselves. 
    • This answered my original question on the effectiveness of antidepressants in the long-term!
  • The most common symptom of depression doesn't always have to be feeling sad. It's just as common for people to feel: numb, flat, unmotivated, and tired. Also, some may feel unable to find pleasure, even in things they used to like. That being said, others may certainly feel more tearfulness and sadness. Sometimes, people have thoughts that life is not worth living or that they would be better off not living anymore. This is the most serious and dangerous symptom of depression, and is a big red flag that the person needs the help of a mental health specialist IMMEDIATELY. 
From here, we moved onto the portrayal of depression in media. Although I had hoped to discuss four movies/books (13 Reasons Why, Big Hero 6, Inside Out, and Frozen), I could only analyze two of them with the therapists as they hadn't seen/read some of the other examples. If you guys have seen/read anything else that you thing portrays depression accurately/inaccurately, let me know in the comments please!
  • Frozen:
    • Scene: When Elsa feels trapped by the family, and is secluded in her room for many years (also, Anna's rejection from Elsa in terms of their sisterly bond)
      • Yes, this does accurately portray depression. However, the reengagement between the two sisters later in the movie isn't natural.

  • Inside Out:
    • Scene: When the family relocates to San Francisco, Riley feels very sad, alone, insecure, and unhappy. 
      • This is yet another accurate scene from Disney! Apparently, Inside Out really hits all the details (you'll definitely see more references to this movie)! πŸ‘

In terms of where these misconceptions stem from, the answer is still the cultural shame and the social stigmas. People don't have accurate information because of the limited ways for the right information to be spread. Mental health issues are not an open topic. Not talked about. People don't ask questions because of the guilt and shame they feel. They're too afraid to ask and get accurate information. Because of all of the misinformation (such as the statements I previously discussed), family members can be rude, and also, people can be their own, harshest critics. To combat this situation, we need more public health campaigns, allowing mental health issues to be more widely and openly addressed in our culture. 

Sorry, I know this post is getting a bit long, but I wanted to talk a little bit more about my on-site experience as an example of the social stigmas we can even unconsciously hold. Although no notable changes have occurred in my plans for my project, there has been an ongoing experience that has surprised me while being onsite. I'd like to provide some background before I begin on what I do exactly on the typical, on-site day. For the most part, I help Jessica at the front desk, attending to client calls, collecting payment, and making appointments. I also make files/folders for new clients, and organize/print out any paperwork or fliers that will be necessary. Here are some pictures of A New Beginning, making it easier for you guys to visualize the environment:

Image result for a new beginning outpatient treatment center
The super, calming front lobby (p.s. the chairs are too soft to be real)

Image result for a new beginning scottsdale
Oh look! You can see the front desk (unfortunately, you can't see me sitting there as I usually do) πŸ˜†

Spending time at the front desk, I got to interact with a lot of the clients, and in doing so, my whole point-of-view on mental health issues changed. Everyone who comes in looks so normal, and I'd never have thought they were struggling with a disorder. This shocked me because I didn't realize that I myself held such shallow stereotypes and misconceptions in mind. But, after this experience, I'm beginning to see that everyone is only human, and everyone truly has their own story. Their own problems. I know that probably sounds cliched, but it was so eye-opening. I'm so grateful for this experience, not only for making a great project, but for teaching me a lot about how I see others. 

I hope you guys like my Week 2 post! Thank you all for following me on this journey, and showing me so much support!

Lots of love πŸ’—,

--Saleena 



Sources:

*Psychologists Think They Found The Purpose Of Depression (2017, February). Retrieved February 14, 2017, from http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/psychologists-think-they-found-the-purpose-of-depression_us_589e58a8e4b080bf74f03c45

33 comments:

  1. Hello Saleena,

    What an insightful post. I'm glad to read your post and hear what Taana said about depression. We live in such a "do it yourself" and "pull yourself up by your own bootstraps" culture that it is difficult to admit when we need help. I am glad that you are encouraging people to find the courage to do this.

    Thank you for putting in the note that those who fight with their depression every day are really very strong people. It's hard to understand what a victory is won when someone is able to live through their depression.

    Thank you for sharing your insights!
    -Ms. Cooney

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Ms. Cooney!
      I'm so glad to hear that you liked my post :D It shows me that my blog really is making an impact by helping get rid of the social stigmas surrounding mental health issues to build a more supporting community, and get people the help they need and deserve without judgement. Really, anyone who fights against their mental health issue is so much stronger than we realize, because he/she is truly working to make him/herself be the best he/she can be <3 Thank you for all of your support!

      Delete
  2. Hey Saleena! I had no idea that depression was increasing at such a rapid rate. It makes me worried about the future and how people are going to cope with so much going on in their lives. What i love most is how Disney is doing a great job of depicting all different types of disoerders. I always assumed that depression was associated with people that have experieneced traumatizing events in their life. Its really hard to hear that depresion can decrease a persons life span. I always thought it lead to the deterioration of a persons mental health, not their overall health. Thank you! This was an amazing article to read!! :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hey Pooja! I think people have different ways of coping, but hopefully people can starting seeing therapy as a more preferable option and be more open to the idea of it. Disney is pretty amazing, if I can say so myself. They put a lot of work into Inside Out, and I think I'm really starting to see it. I'm glad this post helped in clearing out some of those misconceptions; it tells me I'm walking on the right path to my goal in the project :D <3

      Delete
  3. Once again, a wonderful and very detailed post. Ms. Cooney took the words right from my fingers, by commenting on people who fight depression being very strong people. It can at times prove extremely difficult to manage day to day in our culture without a disorder. Having to battle through day to day challenges with a disorder such as depression takes an immense amount of strength.

    I greatly appreciate you placing a strong emphasis on social stigmas and how harsh they can be without us even realizing.

    Keep these amazing posts coming! I cannot wait for next weeks. Oh, and your office looks nice and calming.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hey Mr. Chadwick! That's the sad truth in our society. People shouldn't have to feel trapped by their disorder and deemed weak. What they're facing is so difficult, and that they're trying to push through it is such an accomplishment. I'm glad that I'm treading on the right path to get rid of those social stigmas, even those in my own mind, reaching the goal of my project. Thank you so much for all of your support :D Also, the office is very calming, especially with the quiet background music!

      Delete
  4. I (obviously) loved your post, and I think it dialogues with my work over at Flake's office. The Senate recently voted on another gun control law related to people with mental illnesses accessing guns. Stepping out of the quicksand that is politics, I did have a lot of people calling to tell me that the mental health services in Arizona need significantly more work and funding (and they do). I thought this was interesting, because it's a point where mental health and politics (who's going to pay so that the average person can receive the care they need?) collide.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hey Nicole! I'm happy to hear you love my post (I won't take it for granted) :D I hope that people can start seeing beyond the social stigmas, and build an even more supporting community for those with mental health issues even through politics. Especially considering the current political turmoil, it's a great opportunity for people to use their voice and make a difference!

      Delete
  5. Hey Saleena! I'm always looking forward to reading your blog posts because each time I develop a new insight on mental afflictions that I've only heard a a little bit about. As you said in your blog, if only about 7% of adults are depressed, how come 12% take antidepressants? Is it because of the different perception people have of depression? Thanks so much:)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Millie! Awww, thank you so much <3 I'm so happy to hear that you're enjoying my blog. In terms of your question, I'm sorry it wasn't clearer, but I meant to convey that of the 7% of the adults with depression, only 12% take antidepressants. I hope that helps :) Thank you once again :D

      Delete
  6. Another fantastic post, Saleena! It's always so interesting to learn new things about a topic that you think you know. You also work at a very beautiful place. Keep calm and blog on! ;D

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Awww <3 Thank you so much, Kiri :) I also find myself learning so much, even on disorders I thought I knew really well (take anxiety, for example). I can't wait for next week either as it's a disorder I really don't know much about at all! :D

      Delete
  7. Hi Saleena! Blog of the week is very well deserved, with the amount of work and dedication you put forth!! It is great to see you looking at the stigma surrounding mental disorders, in a very enlightening matter. Your blog is so in-depth, all my questions were answered as I went through it. The only bad thing about this research project, is that I can't see you at school anymore!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hey Layla! Thank you so much for all of your support and kind words :D I really appreciate it. I'm glad the posts are easy to follow along with, and answer the questions that may come up in the readers mind. I miss you too <3

      Delete
  8. Hey Saleena! I found this post just as, if not more, interesting as your past one about anxiety, especially due to the misconceptions about depression. I didn't know that one could be depressed when feeling unmotivated and tired, I thought that qualified as more sad and that suicidal thoughts were the only symptoms for depression. With misconceptions like that, I can see why so many people do not seek help, especially if they do not think they're actually depressed at all, just sad.

    That being said, I have a question regarding the treatment of this disorder. You said that people diagnosed with depression get the most beneficial help with a combination of medication and physical exercise. I was wondering do people with this disorder that do seek help actually pull through on these treatments? As in, do they do everything their doctors tell them to do regularly, or does the unmotivated attitude people develop with depression often make them forget or neglect to follow through on their treatment?

    Also, aside from the shame they feel, is the unmotivated symptom often what keeps people with depression from seeking help or being able to help themselves, since they do not find it worth trying to get healthy again?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hello Annalise! I'm so happy that you're enjoying reading my blog, and are finding the posts enlightening. I really hope others can realize the same like you, and we can start a movement to get rid of the social stigmas surrounding all mental health issues. I think that the two elements of the treatment, medication and exercise, work together to cover all aspects of the disorder. The medicine helps to build the motivation in the short-run, whilst the exercise helps fix the behavior for the long-term. The medicine basically provides the boost needed to keep following through the treatment (thought there may be days where one can feel unmotivated, but the therapist can help with that on a case-by-case basis through follow-up appointments). That being said, I think that's how it works, but I'm not a therapist (however, if I'm very wrong, I'll be sure to get back to you on this)! In terms of your second question, I think the unmotivated symptom can lead to both situations. They may not feel like they're worthy of becoming healthy, or they simply don't want to seek help from themselves or others. But, if people can see that others have pulled through this successfully, they can go seek the help they need. I hope that helps answer your questions. Thank you :)

      Delete
    2. Hi ladies, this is Taana. I was reading through the comments and I wanted to clear up a misunderstanding. People with major depression typically get the most benefit from a combination of medication and therapy, not exercise. Regular exercise has been demonstrated to be as effective as antidepressants for some people - so exercise would replace medications, not therapy. Therapy produces the most long-lasting results. Hope that helps! - Taana

      Delete
  9. Great post! One of the sources of depression that you mention is hormones. Since hormones can be impacted by medications taken for other conditions, can depression sometimes result? In these instances, would it be treated in the same way(s)?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hello Ms. Mitrovich! Thank you so much :D In terms of your question, it's best to have an evaluation by a physician for recommendations related to mood changes that may be caused by hormones and/or medication interactions as it varies on a case-by-case basis. I hope that helps!

      Delete
  10. Hey Saleena!
    Awesome post! It amazes me how much research you're able to do in only one week! I think you brought up a great question when you asked if antidepressants were truly effective and I think it's great that you're interacting with the clients. Based on the statistics, why does depression shorten someone's life span and do you know how the rates of depression vary in individualist and collectivist cultures? Again, great work and I'm excited for your next post!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hey Nathan! Thank you so much :D You get a lot done when you're having fun (and time flies by)! In terms of your first question, depression can shorten a lifespan due to several factors. One is suicide, but there is also lack of self-care including lack of medical check-ups and follow up, and lack of compliance with medical recommendations. Lack of social support and isolation may also impact a person’s lifespan. However, with your second question, I'm really not quite sure. I think culture does play an important role, but it is also about the person's him/herself and his/her own attitude. I hope that helps (sorry, I don't know much about the second question)!

      Delete
  11. Hi Saleena! Yet another insightful post! People need to be more aware of different mental conditions, and you summed up exactly what has to be said about depression. I have a small question, is there a scale or so to observe varying degrees of depression, and are there physical tests done to diagnose depression, or is it strictly based off of a psychological evaluation? Thank you. Can't wait to read more and become more aware of the different conditions!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hey Sri! I'm go glad my blog is shedding a new light on mental health issues :D To make a diagnosis, therapists use the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. There are qualifications regarding symptoms as well as severity and frequency of symptoms for each disorder. There are no current medical/physical tests for depressive disorders. Some people experience sub-clinical symptoms, meaning they do not quite meet the requirements for a diagnosis. People can still pursue therapy for their symptoms, but the services may not be covered by insurance without a diagnosis. Hope that helps answer your question :)

      Delete
  12. Saleena! This is an amazing post and I learned a lot! Did you look into with your research how important the support system someone has is? Such as a good school, solid friends, family willing to help, etc? I'm pretty sure those would help, but it would be cool to see how your project viewed these. Keep up the great work and I can't wait to read more!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hey Julia! I'm so happy to hear that you're enjoying my blog posts :D I'm so grateful to have such a wonderful audience! Although I didn't focus-in on the support system, I can provide some insight into your question. The support system one has plays a huge role in reducing the risk of depression, and in the recovery process. Having all of the elements you mentioned can help in the environmental aspect of depression, but not in the genetics department of depression. I hope that helps! I'll be addressing the support system a lot more in next week's post :D

      Delete
  13. Hi Saleena!
    Congratulations on Blog of the Week! You deserve it. Your post this week was really interesting, and I had a few questions. What constitutes as a major depressive episode? Is this different from the everyday numbness and emptiness you mentioned people feel? Also, do you think different cultures have several kinds of stigmas towards these mental illnesses that need to be approached in different ways? For example, some of the myths you've mentioned are things I've seen in my own culture that maybe aren't as prevalent in American culture. Thank you! Your project is super interesting, and I can't wait to see where it takes you!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hello Nitya! Thank you so much for your kind words of support :D In terms of your first question, a major depressive episode consists of five or more of the following symptoms: depressed mood most of the day, nearly every day; diminished interest or pleasure in all/almost all, activities of the day nearly every day; significant weight loss when not dieting or weight gain; insomnia or hypersomnia nearly every day; psychomotor agitation or retardation nearly every day; fatigue or loss of energy; feelings of worthlessness or excessive or inappropriate guilt, diminished ability to think or concentrate, or indecisiveness; and/or recurrent thoughts of death/suicidal thoughts. This is different from the everyday numbness and emptiness because it involves a variety of factors that don't necessarily have to be emotional aspects. For your second question, I do think that different cultures have their own stigmas that would need to be approached in different ways, as some cultures may be more liberal or conservative in their view on mental health issues (changing the prevalence of certain stigmas). I hope that helps! Let me know if you still have any questions :)

      Delete
  14. Hey, Saleena! I thought I already wrote a comment for your blog, but I was just looking back and I realized that I guess I didn't. So, sorry for being late to comment. Your posts always teach me so many things, and I love it! So, for depression, do you have any idea what factors are causing it to increase at such a rapid rate? Also, I love your section on how these disorders are getting portrayed in the media. I love your analysis on Frozen and Inside Out (there's a theory (you can tell me if it's true or not) that says when Riley's emotion control board thing turned grey, that showed that she was feeling depression, which showed how depression is different from the emotion of sadness). Anyway, my real question is with your expertise and immense knowledge, how would you analyze Big Hero 6? If this takes too much of your time, I'm sorry and you can just ignore the question. Again, I love your blog, congratulations on winning blog of the week, and I can't wait to read more!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Korina! That's alright :) Thank you for all of your support :D There are numerous potential explanations for increasing rates of depression. These can be seen using cross-cultural studies. It appears that general and specific characteristics of modernization (ex. a country's GDP per capita) correlate with higher lifetime risk of a mood disorder. Chronic diseases, decreasing social capita, and increasing inequality may also be potential factors, contributing to poor physical health and affecting the incidence and treatment of depression. The media section is my favorite as well! In terms of the Inside Out theory you mentioned, I think that sounds very accurate as there is a difference between simply feeling sad and feeling depressed. For your most important question, I was hoping to analyze how social structures impact a person's recovery from depression (basically, I wanted to show how Hiro, through the help of his brother's friends and Baymax, goes through the grief process of losing his brother and getting revenge). I hope that helps (that was a very fun question to answer :D)!

      Delete
  15. Hi Saleena! Your research is coming along very nicely, which makes your blog so much fun to read. I'm really enjoying it! I was wondering if there are any other causes of depression? Are the ones you listed that major ones? Additionally, is one's ability to overcome depression made harder or easier with different causes? (does one cause of depression make it harder to overcome than another?) Thank you!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hello Vindhya! I'm glad to hear that you're enjoying my blog :D There may be different causes on a case-by-case basis; however, the ones I mentioned are the most common, general factors. In terms of your second question, I would say different forms of depression are more challenging to overcome based again on severity and frequency of symptoms coupled with the patient’s ability to comply with recommendations made in their treatment. For instance, people may be noncompliant with medication or therapy recommendations. Possible iterations of this are: attending therapy less frequently than recommended, not following recommendations for higher levels of care, not being willing to practice skills or make behavioral changes taught in therapy, not being willing to take medication if recommended, and/or family not being willing to engage in family therapy when recommended. These issues can prolong the period of time before the person begins to feel relief from their symptoms. I hope that helps!

      Delete
  16. Hello Saleena, I like your research, being that it studies disorders. Learning that anybody can have depression is shocking to say the least. I also really like your puns and the references you are using (I like Disney a lot). I'm excited what else you're going to cover over the next couple of weeks.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hey Chris! Psychology is a very interesting field, and I am so happy to be able to look more into the disorders side of it. Mental health issues are more common than people realize, demonstrating just how little they are discussed. Thank you so much; I'm glad to hear you are enjoying my blog and the Disney references :D

      Delete